Attitude of Customers towards Branded and Non-Branded Gold Jewellers - A Study

 

Dr. M. Vasan

Assistant Professor of Commerce, A.V.V.M. Sri Pushpam College (Autonomous), Poondi - 613 503, Thanjavur Dt. Tamilnadu, India.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: m.vasan@yahoo.com

 

ABSTRACT:

This paper is focused on the attitude of gold buyers towards branded and non-branded jewellers. The objective of the study is to analyse the reasons for preferring branded and non-branded gold jewellers and satisfaction of buyers towards gold jewellers. This study will useful to the owners of gold jewellers for understanding the choices and preferences of buyers, the criteria adopted by buyers in selecting a particular jeweller, in adopting a suitable pricing strategy, and in devising suitable marketing strategies, so as to serve their customers in a better way. 

 

KEYWORDS: Gold Purchase, Buyers Behaviour,  Attitude of Gold Buyers, Branded Jewellery.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

In India, gold is considered as a glamorous metal and as a status symbol among the people. It tends to have religious as well as cultural significance. India is deemed to be the hub of the global jewellery market. The Jewellery sector in India plays a significant role in the economy which contributes around 7 percent in the GDP and 15.71 percent in India’s total merchandise exports. It is also provides employment to over 4.64 million workers. This sector is contributing in a big way to the country’s foreign exchange earnings. The average annual consumption of gold in India is between 700 and 800 tonnes.

 

 

 

 

The jewellery sector in India is highly unorganised having only 4-5 percent share as organized. So, it provides an opportunity to organied gold jewelers can to enter into the Indian market. Now there are more than 15,000 players across the country in this sector. There are about 4,50,000 goldsmiths spread throughout the country. There are numerous of national players who are engaged in organised sector such as Tata (Tanishq), Peacock Jewelers Private Ltd., Joy Aluklas, etc. Multi-national jewellery brands such as Tiffany, Christian Dior, Bvlgari, Harry Winston and Zales are to be entered after the approval the Government. There are numerous factors which motivates the customers to buy branded jewellery over unbranded jewellery. These factors includes attractive and innovative designs, better quality, purity, variety, durability, lightweight, comfortability to wear, uniqueness, trust, specific product benefits or shopping experience, status symbol, etc. Hence, these factors are affecting the behaviour of the customers in purchasing jewellery. With this background, the present study focused on the attitude of gold buyers towards branded and non-branded jewellery.  

 

 

LITERATURE REVIEW:

Jain (2013) found that female customers are becoming more aware about branded jewellery. Berad et al. (2015) have identified that design, price, purity, image, variety, display, service, promotion and offers, family and friends are the major factors influencing purchase decision of gold jewellery. Hence, most of the respondents were prefer to buy in branded jewellery. Gomathy and Devi (2015) have examined that maximum number of buyers are aware about branded jewellery. Rawal (2015) has examined gold buyers are prefer to select branded jewellery products from the branded shops. Ramachandran and Karthick (2014) found that branded jewellery products have a unique style and more varieties compared with the unbranded jewellery. The study conducted by Jyothi and Babu (2014) and Raju and Kumar (2013) have identified that gold purity, varieties, brand image, service quality, advertisement, brand familiarity, promotional schemes, offers, celebrity endorsement are the major factors which affect the behaviour of the buyers. Asha and Christopher (2014) identified that majority of the customers purchase gold jewellery in the occasion of marriages, anniversaries, birthdays, festivals and offers. Vadra and Malhotra (2014) examined that the buying behaviour was highly influenced by jewellery designs in the branded showrooms. Walia et al. (2013) identified the factors which inspire the consumer to buy in the branded jewellery such as quality, status, buy back schemes, certification of gold and zero installment schemes.

                        

IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY:

The Erode city is witnessed the rapid growth in the field of handmade jewellery in the past many decades. Now, this city is facing a cut-throat competition and challenge from the branded jewellery. This is further boosted by a few local manufacturers and traders initiating the concept of retail branding. Thus, the need has arisen to conduct a perception study of buyers on branded jewellery to measure the future of this line of business and also to study the future of direction and strategies being adopted by the existing traders to face the completions from the branded jewellery. Hence, the outcome of this study will be of immense help to the owners of gold jewellers in understanding the choices and preferences of buyers, the criteria adopted by buyers in selecting a particular jeweller, in adopting a suitable pricing strategy, and in devising suitable marketing strategies, so as to serve their customers in a better way. 

 

STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM:

Gold is a time tested asset.  Even when the price increases, people never hesitated to purchase it. Gold has been traditionally the desired asset for Indians. India is being the world’s second largest gold jewellery market. According to World Gold Council, about 10 percent of world’s gold is in India’s possession. Gold is not just a mere investment for Indians. It is intertwined into the fabric of the Indian culture, traditions and religious beliefs. It is also considered as a status symbol which useful in measuring the wealth of a person in the society. The branded gold jewellery division occupies a significant share in the total jewellery market. It is due to the most of the Indian buyers still considers jewellery as an investment. The attitudes and perceptions of buyers of gold jewellery as drastically changed. Most of the Indian jewellery buyers are getting more and more trend conscious. In this changing scenario, well-defined, strategic marketing policies are need for creating brand image among the people.

 

There is limited number of researches carried out to discover the gold jewellery in particular the branded gold jewellery which falls under organized sector. 85 percent of the gold jewellery is still conquered by unorganised gold jewellery sector. Thus this study analyses the various perceptional aspects of gold buyers which influence in purchasing the branded gold jewellery and thereby help to design a suitable market strategies to promote the sale of branded gold jewellery. Based on the aforesaid issues, the following research questions have been probed:

·      What is the basis for selection of gold jeweller?

·      What is the level of the satisfaction of buyers towards gold jewellers?

 

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:

The study has been carried out with the following objectives: 

i)     To know the criteria for selection of gold jewellers.

ii)   To identify the reasons for preferring branded and Non-branded gold jewellers.

iii) To measure the statisfaction level of buyers towards gold jewellers.

 

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:

The descriptive research method is used to analyse the consumer preference for branded gold jewellery over unbranded gold jewellery. Both primary and secondary sources of data have been used. A well-structured questionnaire used to collect the required data from the respondents. The questionnaire comprises gold consumption pattern, reasons for purchasing from non-branded gold jewellers and level of satisfaction towards preferred gold jeweller. The secondary data has been collected from the books, journals, web portals, etc. The sample size of 140 respondents conveniently selected to collect the necessary data from the gold purchasers in Erode City. The data collected from the respondents have been coded and tabulated to suit the requirement of the study. Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS) have been used for analysing the data. The statistical tools such as Description Statistics, Friedman’s test, K-means cluster analysis and Chi-square test have been used to analyse and interpret the data.

 

GOLD PURCHASE PATTERN OF BUYERS:

In this section, gold purchase pattern of buyers is analysed with respect to their amount invested in gold, frequency of purchase, influencer in the purchase decision, reasons for purchasing gold, type of gold jewellery purchased, criteria for selection of gold jewellery, preferred gold jewellery and reasons for preferring a particular gold jeweller.

 

Table 1: Amount Invested in Gold

Amount Invested in Gold

Frequency

Percent

Below Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg1,00,000

29

20.71

Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg1,00,001-2,00,000

46

32.9

Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg2,00,001- 3,00,000

45

32.1

Above Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg 3,00,000

20

14.28

Total

140

100.0

 

The amount invested in gold by the respondents depicts that 32.9 percent have invested Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg1,00,001-2,00,000, 32.1 percent have invested between Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg2,00,001-3,00,000, 20.71 percent invested less than  Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg1,00,000 and 14.28 percent have invested more than Description: File:Indian Rupee symbol.svg3,00,000 in gold (Table - 1).

 

Table - 2: Frequency of Purchasing Gold

Frequency of Purchase

Frequency

Percent

Monthly

11

7.9

Yearly

66

47.1

Occasionally

63

45.0

Total

140

100.0

 

Frequency of purchasing gold revealed that the 47.1 percent of the respondents have been purchasing gold once in a year followed by 45 percent have been purchasing occasionally and 7.9 percent have been purchasing once in a month (Table - 2).

 

Table 3: Reasons for Gold Purchase

Reasons

Frequency

Percent

Marriage 

30

21.4

Gift

19

13.5

Investment

25

17.8

Personal aspiration

20

14.0

Status

28

20.0

Festival

18

12.8

Total

140

100.0

 

The reasons for purchasing gold indicates that 21.4 percent of the respondents have purchased gold for marriage, 20 percent have purchased gold on auspicious occasions like family functions, Akshayathirudhi, etc., 17.85 percent have purchased gold for investment purposes, 14.28 percent have purchased gold for their personal aspiration, 13.5 percent have purchased gold for gifting to friends and 12.85 percent have purchased gold during festival occasions (Table - 3).

 

Table 4: Type of Gold Jewellery Purchased

Type of Jewellery

Always

Sometimes

Never

Total

Stud /Earrings

11

77

52

140

Bangles / Bracelets

14

73

53

140

Finger rings

26

62

51

140

Necklace / Chains

67

46

27

140

Coins

12

25

93

140

Others

20

65

55

140

 

The type of gold jewellery preferred by the respondents shows that majority of the buyers have purchased finger rings, followed by stud/ earrings, coins, bangles/bracelets and necklace/ chains (Table - 4).

 

Table 5: Criteria for Selection of Gold Jewellery

Variables

Mean

Std. Deviation

Mean Rank

x2 Test

Sig

Quality of gold

3.66

1.227

3.84

28.418

 

.000

Workmanship

3.51

1.226

3.40

Comfort of wearing

3.85

1.229

4.01

Price

3.41

1.275

3.37

Antique value

3.31

1.270

3.19

Trendy

3.34

1.301

3.20

 

The result of Friedman’s Chi-square test shows that there is a significant difference found in the criteria for selection of gold jewellery (P=<0.05). The mean rank revealed the fact that the comfort of wearing, quality of gold, workmanship, price, trendy and antique value are the prime factors considered at the time of selecting gold jewellery (Table - 5).

 

GOLD PURCHASERS’ PREFERENCE TOWARDS BRANDED AND NON-BRANDED JEWELLERS:

Buying preference is a process, wherein various available mutually exclusive alternatives for buying are evaluated by the buyers. It can generally be made by the respondents after thoroughly scrutinizes the pros and cons of each alternatives. Keeping in mind, preferred jeweller, reasons for preferring a particular jeweler, sources of information about gold jewellers, and satisfaction towards preferred gold jeweller have been taken into consideration.

 

 

 

Table 6: Preferred Gold Jeweller

Preferred Jeweller

Frequency

Percent

Branded

82

58.57

Non-branded

58

41.42

Total

140

100.0

 

Most of the gold purchasers (58.57 percent) have preferred to purchase from branded gold jewellers and 41.42 percent of the gold purchasers have preferred non-Branded gold jewellers (Table - 6).

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 7: Reasons for Purchasing Gold from Branded Jewellers

Variables

Mean

Std. Deviation

Mean Rank

x2 Test

Sig.

Reliability 

3.96

1.079

4.33

26.446

 

.000

Competitive price

3.83

1.112

4.19

Goodwill

4.34

.828

5.22

Advertisement

4.17

1.079

4.90

Reasonable wastage and Making charges

3.85

1.314

4.38

Wide range of collections

3.87

1.168

4.28

Brand image

3.89

1.245

4.34

Quality

3.84

1.248

4.37

 

The result of Friedman’s Chi-Square test shows that there is a significant difference (P=<0.05) found in the reasons for purchasing gold from the branded jewellers (Table - 7). Goodwill is a major reason for buying gold from the branded jeweller (Mean Rank= 5.22), followed by advertisements (Mean Rank=4.90), reasonable wastage and making charges (Mean Rank=4.38), quality (Mean Rank=4.37), brand image (Mean Rank=4.34) and competitive price (Mean Rank=4.19).

 

Table 8: Reasons for Purchasing Gold from Non-branded Jewellers

Variables

Mean

Std. Deviation

Mean Rank

X2 Test

Sig.

Able to order designs according to my desire

3.84

1.148

3.76

13.909

.000

Free from taxes

3.57

1.067

3.37

Hereditary bonding 

3.83

1.193

3.72

Better Payment terms of local Jewellers

3.39

1.273

3.11

Low making charges  

3.56

1.337

3.50

 

The result of Friedman’s Chi-Square test shows that there is a significant difference (P=<0.05) found in the reasons for purchasing from non-branded gold jewellers (Table - 8). The prime reason for purchasing gold from the non-branded jewellers is buyers can able to order designs according to their desire (Mean Rank=3.76), followed by hereditary bonding (Mean Rank=3.72), low making charges (Mean Rank=3.50) and free from taxes (Mean Rank=3.37).   

 

Table 9: Preferred Gold Jewellers

Gold Jewellers

Frequency

Percent

Malabar gold

20

14.3

Tata Gold 

31

22.1

Kalyan jewellers

19

13.6

Joy Alukkas                 

30

21.4

AVR Swarna Mahal

25

17.9

Others

15

10.7

Total

140

100.0

The preferred jeweller for purchasing gold indicates that 22.1 percent have preferred Tata Gold, 21.4 percent have preferred Joy Alukkas, 17.9 percent have preferred AVR Swarna Mahal, 14.3 percent have preferred Malabar Gold and 13.6 percent have preferred Kalyan Jewellers and 10.7 percent selected in other show rooms (Table - 9).

 

Table 10: Sources of Information about Gold Jewellers

Sources of Information

Frequency

Percent

Friends / Relatives

52

37.1

News papers and Magazines

48

34.3

Radio / Television

20

14.3

Hoardings and Banners

20

14.3

Total

140

100.0

 

In the various sources of information, friends and relatives (37.1 percent) constitute a major source of information, followed by Radio/ Television, hoardings and banners and newspapers and magazines (Table - 10).

 

BUYERS’ SATISFACTION WITH GOLD JEWELLERS:

Satisfaction is a person’s feeling of pleasure or dissatisfaction and whether the buyer is satisfied after purchase depends upon the performance of products in relation to expectations of the buyers. If the performance is not up to the expectations, the buyer is dissatisfied. If the performance matches the expectations, the buyer is satisfied. If the performance exceeds the expectations of a buyer is highly satisfied or delighted. The level of satisfaction of gold buyers might be varied with products and services offered by the Jewellers. In this connection, non-parametric Friedman’s test has been used to find out the significant difference in the buyers’ satisfaction with gold Jewellers.

 

Table 11: Buyers’ Satisfaction towards Gold Jewellers

Variables

Mean

Std. Deviation

Mean Rank

X2 Test

Sig.

Wide range of collections

3.64

1.415

5.48

37.175

 

.000

Wastage and Making charges

3.36

1.288

4.58

Exchange offers

3.81

1.256

5.55

Discounts and free gifts

4.14

.941

6.29

Store atmosphere

3.63

1.153

5.07

Purity and Quality of gold

3.98

1.028

5.86

Salesman responsiveness

3.68

1.183

5.14

Price

3.91

1.065

5.58

Service quality

3.89

1.145

5.69

Advertisement

3.96

1.082

5.76

 

The result of Friedman’s Chi-Square test shows that there is a significant difference (P=<0.05) found in the buyers’ satisfaction towards gold Jewellers (Table - 11). The mean ranks revealed the fact that the buyers are more satisfied with discounts and free gifts (Mean Rank=6.29) followed by purity and quality of gold (Mean Rank=5.86) and price (Mean Rank=5.58). The buyers are more dissatisfied with wastage and making charges (Mean Rank=4.58). 

 

CLASSIFICATION OF PURCHASERS’ SATISFACTION TOWARDS GOLD JEWELLERS:

In this section the classification of different type of clusters based on attitude of gold purchasers towards jewellers. K-means cluster analysis is applied to identify heterogeneous groups of gold purchasers. This analysis is helpful to identify the different groups of gold purchasers with homogeneous qualities.

 

Table 12: Level of Satisfaction with Gold Jewellers

Level of Satisfaction

Frequency

Percent

Medium

38

27.1

High

65

46.5

Low

37

26.4

Total

140

100.0

 

The final cluster centre table revealed that there exist three heterogeneous groups of gold purchasers based on their satisfaction with jewellers. The second cluster of buyers of 46.4 percent are in the high level of satisfaction with their jewellers, 27.1 percent of the buyers are in the moderate level satisfaction and 26.4 percent of them in the low level of satisfaction with their preferred jewellers (Table - 12).

 

Table - 13: Preferred Gold Jeweller and Level of Satisfaction with Preferred Gold Jeweller

Preferred Jeweller

Level of Satisfaction

Total

Medium

High

Low

Branded

F

9

52

21

82

%

11.0

63.4

25.6

100.0

Non-Branded

F

29

13

16

58

%

50.0

22.4

27.6

100.0

Total

F

38

65

37

140

%

27.1

46.5

26.4

100

 

Preferred gold jeweller and level of satisfaction with gold jewellers indicates that 63.4 percent of buyers of branded stores are in the high level of satisfaction (Table - 13). 

 

Table – 14: Association between Preferred Gold Jeweller and Level of Satisfaction with Preferred Gold Jeweller

Tests

Value

df

Sig.

Pearson Chi-Square

12.257

1

.000

Likelihood Ratio

12.610

1

.002

Linear-by-Linear Association

3.826

1

.040

 

Hypothesis:

There is no association between the preferred gold jeweller and satisfaction of gold buyers.

 

The chi-square test reveals that the Pearson chi-square value is equal to 12.257 and likelihood ratio of 12.610 along with linear by linear association of 3.826. All the probabilistic values are significant at 5 percent level (P=<0.05). Hence, the null hypothesis is rejected. Therefore, it is concluded that there is an association found between preferred gold Jeweller and level of satisfaction (Table - 14).

 

CONCLUSION:

The branded Jewellery segment occupies only a meagre share of the total Jewellery market in India. Today, the branded Jewellers are spread throughout the country, meeting the demands of the consumers from all parts of the country. The study proved that goodwill, reasonable wastage and making charges, reliability, quality, brand image, advertisement, wide range of collections and competitive price are the base for the selection of branded store. The study findings will explicitly serve as an eye-opener for the gold jewellers to understand the attitude of the buyers.

 

REFERENCES:

1.     Amrinder Singh., and Pritpal Singh. (2018). Factors Determining Online Purchase Behaviour of the Consumers in Punjab - A Study of Urban and Rural Consumers. Asian Journal of Management, 9(1), 133-139.

2.     Asha, K., and Christopher, S.E. (2014). A Study on Buying Behaviour of Customers towards Branded and Non-branded Gold Jewellery with preference to Kanyakumari District. International Journal of Management, 5(10), 105-114.

3.     Balanaga Gurunathan, K., and Muniraj, S. (2012).  Impacts of Customer Awareness and Buyer Behaviour on Buying Jewellery Products with Special References to Tamil Nadu State. European Journal of Social Sciences, 29(3), 337-342.

4.     Berad, N.R., Agarwal, M., Vaity, R., Khan, S., Bhujbal, D. and Deshpande, G. (2015). A Comparative Study on the Consumer’s Preference towards Branded Jewellery over Non-branded Jewellery in Nasik City. International Journal of Applied Services Marketing Perspectives Journals, 4(1), 1419-1426.

5.     Gomathy, C. and Devi, Y. (2015). A Study on Consumers’ Awareness and Perception about Branded Jewellery. Indian Journal of Applied Research, 5(3), 71-72.

6.     Jain, N. (2013). A Comparative Study of Indian Women’s Perception towards Branded and Non-branded Jewellery in Jaipur City. Applied Research and Development Institute Journal, 7(7), 59-64.

7.     Jyothi, M.B. and Babu, K.V. (2014). An Empirical Study on Consumer Preference towards Branded Jewellery in Tirupati. Global Journal for Research Analysis, 3(5), 92-94.

8.     Kavita Saxena. (2016). A Study of Buying Behaviour of Customers towards Branded and Non-Branded Gold Jewellery with Reference to Meerut City. Journal of Commerce and Trade, 11(1), 109-114.

9.     Kumar and Varadaraj. (2013). A Study on Buying Behaviour of Women Customer’s towards Jewellery Products with Special Reference to Tirupur City. Indian Journal of Applied Research, 3(5). 21.

10.   Kumar, A. (2012). The Changing Buying Behavior of Customers in Organized Retail Sectors of Pune City. International Journal of Research in Social Sciences, 2(1), 242-263.

11.   Pankaj Kadyan., Dhirender Singh., Ranjan Kumar., and Smita Mehendale. (2018) Customer Satisfaction through Service Quality: A Methodological and Thematic Review. Asian Journal of Management, 9(1), 791-796.

12.   Peter, Paul, J and Olson, Jerry, C. (1993). Consumer Behaviour and Marketing Strategy, Boston, Irwin.

13.   Prabhakar Rajkumar, K. (2010). Factor Influencing Consumer Perception of Gold Purchase in Four Major Districts of Tamil Nadu. Apeejay Journal of Management and Technology, 5, 58-63.

14.   Raju, K.V. and Kumar, D.P. (2013). A Study on Consumer Preference on Branded Jewellery in Hyderabad. International Journal of Sales and Marketing Management, 2(5), 23-34.

15.   Ramachandran, K.K. and Karthick, K.K. (2014). A Study on the Perception of Customers towards Branded Jewellery. Proceeding of Annual Tokyo Business Research Conference.

16.   Rawal, K.R. (2015). A Study of Consumer Buying Behaviour for Purchasing of Diamond Jewellery from Branded Retailers. Tactful Management Research Journal, 99-104.

17.   Shridhar, R., and Prasad Rao, P. (2018). Factors Affecting Retailer’s Perception towards Reliance Telecom Services in Durg Region-with Special Reference to JK Communication. Asian Journal of Management, 9(1), 685-691.

18.   Srinivas Kumar, N. (2015). An Empirical Study on the Influence of Independent Marketing Variables on the Purchasing Decision of Selected Personal Care Products. Asian Journal of Management, 6(2), 128-134.

19.   The Hindu, Gold remains safe haven amid global gloom, February 20, 2009.

20.   The Hindu. Salem Edition, November 9, 2014.

21.   Vadra, R., and Malhotra, G. (2015). Customer Perception towards Branded Jewellery in India. www.docslide/documents /category/documents.html, 1-20.

22.   Vasan, M. (2006). Consumer Behaviour and Brand Preferences of Britannia Biscuits - An Empirical Study with reference to Salem, Tamil Nadu. Indian Journal of Marketing, 36(8), 17-21and39.

23.   Vasan, M. (2006). Customer Satisfaction on ICICI Bank Debit Cards. Economic Challenger, 33(9), 71-74.

24.   Vasan, M. (2007). Retail Industry in India - A Review. Economic Challenger, 36 (9), 25-30.

25.   Vasan, M. (2011). Consumer Shopping Behaviour in Retail Stores - A Case of Salem District. International Journal of Marketing and Management Research, 2 (7), 226-237.

26.   Vasan, M. (2014). Customers’ Satisfaction towards Internet Banking of ICICI Bank Limited - A Study in Erode City, Vidushi, 6and7 (1), 13-26.

27.   Vasan, M. (2014). Marketing Management. Coimbatore: Bornfring Publishers.

28.   Vasan, M. (2015). Gold Buyers’ Behaviour. New Delhi: EduPedia Publications Pvt, Ltd.

29.   Vasan, M. (2016). Consumers’ Perception towards Viral Marketing in Erode City. International Journal of Research and Business Innovation, 2(1), 13-18.

30.   Walia, K., Kaur, I. and Kaur, G. (2013). Customer Perception regarding Branded Jewellery. Asian Journal of Research in Marketing, 2 (2), 17-23.

31.   www.managementstudyguide.com/goldpurchase.htm

32.   www.sec.gov/divisions/marketreg/ratingagency.htm

33.   Yeong Bin Cho, Yoon Ho Cho and Soung Hie Kim. (2005). Mining Changes in Customer Buying Behavior for Collaborative Recommendations. Elsevier Expert Systems with Applications, 28(2), 359-369.

34.   Yoganandan, G., and Prabhukumar, G. (2015). Consumer Buying Behaviour towards Books in Erode City. International Journal of Research, 2(1), 609-614.

 

 

 

 

 

Received on 08.06.2018       Modified on 18.07.2018

Accepted on 08.08.2018      © A&V Publication all right reserved

Int. J. Rev. and Res. Social Sci. 2018; 6(3): 261-266.

DOI: 10.5958/2454-2687.2018.00025.4